All Episodes

Maybe the real Havana syndrome was the friends we made along the way.

STOP LOOKING AT THE DATE.

IT ALL COMES DOWN TO THIS. WHATEVER THE HELL THIS IS.

As the WCCW creeps ever closer to crowning an ultimate victor, what new and exciting ways can we find to totally ruin your bracket? There’s only one way to find out!

The utter ridiculousness continues as we round out the WCCW regionals with all 16 contestants in the Global and Planetary Divisions of the NCAAA.

It’s a whole episode about the biology of The Last of Us in an attempt to tap into the zeitgeist!

No podcast about the strange and unusual would be complete without a month-long, four-part tournament of 32 different cults competing head to head! NOT ONE SUCH PODCAST. Here’s the first of those four parts!

Momo money, Momo problems.

(Also Wyatt talks about Ohio.)

Stuff dies all the time, and sometimes those dead things are weird looking! This is two of those times.

Boy howdy, if this were the sort of podcast that had separate seasons, this episode sure would be the start of a new one! But it isn’t, so it’s not.

In which Wyatt firmly grips an apple for about two hours

In spite of others’ efforts to the contrary, October just keeps happening! And so, too, do the guests (which are, yes, still of the special variety).

October continues! And the guests? Oh they’re special all right.

October begins, and with it, a whole month of special guests! How else would we make this month stand out?

An episode coming out early?! That’ll be the day! And that day is in fact specifically today, as August Around the World reaches its exciting Caribbean conclusion. Put on absolutely all of the sunscreen and listen along!

The month marches on, and still no Wyatt?? Luckily additional assistance can be found at this next stop of August Around the World: Ireland!

August Around the World continues, though not without incident...

It’s once again that special time of year when the boys get their traveling shoes on (??) and start telling stories around the world! Everything is probably going to go exactly as planned!

The nationwide journey continues with ALMOST the last of the states Wyatt and Jake have specifically lived in (Maryland! Minnesota!) Also the boys come dangerously close to actually reviewing a beer.

Hidden among two spooky eyewitness accounts each, Wyatt and Jake have respectively hidden a first-person tale that they themselves have fabricated.

Having a wren around will prevent one from drowning having a wren around will prevent one from drowning having a wren around will prevent one from drowning having a wren around will prevent one from drowning having a wren around…

Everything is exactly as originally planned in this final episode of March! And what exactly IS planned? Bugs.

The boys are back, with another response to a nonsense prompt!

An unprecedented SECOND consecutive week of very-nearly-SEO-friendly episode titles finds the boys examining… nouns, I guess?

An impromptu prompt leads to a rare example of an episode whose title actually reflects its content!

It’s an episode about darkness! Just, like, the general concept of it. But also stuff IN it!

It’s donkey o’clock, motherfuckers.

What’s that sound? I mean, other than the whole “podcast” thing? Oh ho, it’s yet another episode ABOUT sounds!

The saga continues, as your intrepid hosts continue not to venture outside of the American northeast!

Could these animals talk? Or was each one just another dumb ol’ Clever Hans?

Fantastical exploits of the 19th century lead the boys on a slog through what can be best described as “ultraviolet prose”. And an unintentional amount of bat people!

First-time listener? Probably don't start with this one 😅

Fantastical exploits of the 19th century lead the boys on a slog through what can be best described as “ultraviolet prose”. And an unintentional amount of bat people!

YOU do all the hard work so that WE can create one of our least accessible episodes for new listeners! Also a beer happens.

All good things must come to an end, but also August Around the World has to as well. In any case, it’s Kenya time!

The back half of August Around the World brings the show to Ecuador, where the animals are plentiful and the term “big boned” has a whole new meaning!

August continues to go around the world or whatever, all thanks to a purely arbitrary programming decision two years ago!

It’s this year’s first installment of August Around the World, and that means both alien and ghostly Thailand tales!

This week’s episode features luminous ghost children and a bunch of visual content presented in an audio medium. We’re good at this!

What’s that sound? It’s either a signal of the End Times, metal stuff, a weird fish, various hoaxes, a microwave weapon, something completely psychological – or it’s the latest episode of Superduperstitious!

YES you heard right: the much beloved recurring segment you all have been hankering for and definitely haven’t totally forgotten about is BACK.

It’s once again time for the boys to take a break from trying!

It’s long past time for another E.T.-centric episode, so this one features a pair of stories covering the whole UFOeuvre!

Gotta love the eps when you do all the work for us.

Palm trees are amazing.

Comedian, podcast host, and generally curious guy ALEX SCHMIDT joins the show to talk about some surprisingly creepy things!

This one’s about weird furniture.

The 2020 season was a wash. It’s been two long years and 72 episodes since the last time we did it. That’s right: it’s cult tournament time.

Once upon a time, etc., etc., it’s a fairy tale themed episode of Superduperstitious!

Spook lights, baby! That’s the name of the game this week.

Old Nick is back with some more stories to share, which can only mean JUDGEMENT TIME.

This week’s episode asks the question on all our minds: Is ideas bread?

It’s another cursèd object roundup on this week’s Superduperstitious!

The boys once again sing the unprompted praises of Annihilation in this thinly-veiled excuse for Jake to talk about cave stuff!

The start of a new year means some time talk on Superduperstitious!

The boys are back again, with some kooks and spooks for the books! (For the purposes of this description text, pretend that those three words rhyme.)

After a particularly rough fortnight of PhDing, Wyatt deserves a break. This episode is that!

Well wouldn’t you know it, there IS one more guest appearance in store this month, just in time for Halloween itself!

October has one last meandering interview up its sleeve, and this one is all Halloween all the time!

As Halloween draws ever closer, it’s time for Wyatt and Jake to once again show their directionless interviewing chops!

Autumn: a thing that happens, as far as we know, every single year. North of the Equator, it’s happening RIGHT NOW. This episode is about that!

What do a scary forest hag legend and a weird stretch of Venezuelan road have in common? Nothing. Except that they’re both featured in this week’s potpourri episode!

It’s the Randonautica episode! Who CARES if the hosts aren’t in the same physical location as one another?

August Around the World concludes with an excursion into Scandinavia, and this time, WE’VE GOT COMPANY.

In this installment of August Around the World, things are getting every bit as spooky and mythology-y (?) as they are Latin American!

August Around the World continues, this time in the bigger of the oceans! You know the one.

This is our one hundred and eleventh episode. We are eleventy-one today! What better way to celebrate than to kick off AUGUST AROUND THE WORLD!

“Convince me harder, Daddy”

(Not to be confused with any other podcast’s IP)

We’ve only just begun. We can’t slow down.

We might all still be stuck inside for a while, but there’s plenty of traveling in this week’s ep!

Sometimes, pseudoscience and conspiracy theories are just some goofy, harmless fun. This is not one of those times.

You are simply NOT ready for this one, friends. Emma and Dan, hosts of Real Life Ghost Stories, join the show to talk about ghost stories! Real life ones!

Remember that time in Episode 62 when Wyatt and Jake picked three random creatures apiece to take turns talking about? Yeah, neither do they. So it’s weird artifacts time instead, and not as many of them!

Listen, we’ve been over this before, but it bears repeating: not EVERY episode has to have a theme.

It’s a new beginning for this here podcast, which we assume means literally doing everything over again from the beginning.

Wait, are we still doing this? Wasn’t last week’s the big finale??

That’s it! We did it! This is the last episode of Superduperstitious! That is double digits!

We humans sure do make a lotta STUFF, and we like scary stories, so naturally there are plenty of scary stories ABOUT stuff. That’s right, it’s antiquing time on this episode of Superduperstitious!

Mountains: you can be on them, near them, and maybe even under them if things aren’t going great for you. Here’s an ep about that!

Listener stories are always welcome at Superduperstitious, but not without raising the immortal question: are these stories GOOD?

The Boiz are back, just as you’ve always known them and going by that one name you’ve always called them!

It’s a brand new year! And what better way for Superduperstitious to start that year than by biting off more than it (or at least Jake) can chew?

What was meant to be a Boxing Day episode is now a day later, but you know what? It’s still all winter stories, friend!

Finally, an episode in December! Is it any surprise that it’s about cryptids?

It’s Thanks-friggin-giving, and Wyatt and Jake are thankful for one thing above all else — being together again in the same room! The most obvious way to celebrate this is of course by telling some vaguely holiday-appropriate stories, so that happens.

They’re apes. We KNOW. But how often do you hear anyone say “aping around”? I mean REALLY.

Canine-adjacent stories keep piling up, so it’s time to release the hounds!

It’s Halloween! And it’s a Thursday! The show’s Halloween special finally gets to come out ON the holiday itself! Holy damn!

It’s the final Thursday of October before Halloween itself! And you know what that means: there’s time for one last special guest before pulling out all the spook stops next week.

Another week in October means another exciting guest, but this episode is doing things a bit differently…

The October interviews continue, as does the unintentional “alcohol and spooky stuff” theme of the month so far!

It’s officially the Spooky Times™, and that means the beginning of a full month of awesome guests with tasty tales!

All good things must come to an end, and also so does August Around the World. For the last leg of this particular journey, it’s time to head to Australia!

August Around the World won’t stop until August does! YOUR MOVE, AUGUST.

Wyatt and Jake are determined to stick to their month-long prompt of finding stories from all around the world, even if they’re terrible at it. This week, it’s India!

August Around the World continues, this time in Africa!

Watch out for rogue waves and try to outrun your shadow, it’s time for some international tales! (Note: If the episode prompt is “the British Isles”, don’t be surprised when both hosts just pick Scotland.)

If you thought this podcast was above exploiting the cuteness of a baby animal for attention, think again!

It was only a matter of time before Superduperstitious submitted to the siren song of frontier folktales, so at long last, it’s a full episode of fearsome critters!

Superduperstitious is back at it again! And “it”, in this particular instance, means “supernatural/ghosty stories”. Superduperstitious is back at supernatural/ghosty stories again. It works.

The world is full of weird, and Superduperstitious is determined to visit it all!

Things were feeling just TOO SANE around here, so it’s once again conspiracy time on Superduperstitious!

There’s no time like the present for getting back on our shit, and that shit, of course, is monsters.

We all make mistakes. They don’t always involve depleting all breathable oxygen from a living space or disappearing forever into the jungle, but still.

Pyramid power! Greek robots! Other Ancient Aliens bait!

Spooky spots! Again! Kind of!

It’s always bugs o’clock here at Superduperstitious, because why the hell not?

Rainy day doldrums got you down? That’s no reason not to disrespect the dead!

It’s inexplicably deli time at Superdupersitious!

Any strange story is fair game this week, so the boys tackle some slightly more famous freak occurrences.

The championship cult tournament nobody asked for

Another year of podcasting means Jake and Wyatt are eager to get fully back on their bullshit.

What’s the point believing in spirits and such if it doesn’t involve those spirits being super scary and wanting to mess with us?

It’s a weird world out there, full of rocks and clouds that want to eat you.

Space! There’s an awful lot of it, and yet we practically never talk about it on this friggin’ show. But this episode aims to remedy that!

If you go down to the woods today, you’re in for a big surprise…

It’s spooky in the bedroom once again on Superduperstitious!

The boys have a lot of catching up to do together, and it involves revisiting some interesting past stories of the spooky and strange.

We’re entering parallel universes and hidden worlds galore on this week’s episode of Superduperstitious! But probably not. But maybe!

If we know one thing at Superduperstitious, it’s that animals are weird. They act weird, sometimes they look weird, and frequently they sound weird. So imagine how weird CRYPTIDS must sound! Or just listen to this episode, because that’s what it’s about.

You asked for lost cities, so we give you… towns!

The lights are all out. Your candy is within reach. You’ve got your flashlight, and you’re tucked inside your freshly secreted tent. You’re ready for some spooky stories from the Superduperstitious Halloween special!

For October’s final guest, Superduperstitious is visited by SARA JONES, host of the podcast Laughing in the Dark!

The October Interview Spectacular™®© is still going strong on Superduperstitious, and this time, it hits a little closer to home! But also it was an hour drive to do it? But yeah. It’s good.

October continues, and so do the guests!

October on Superduperstitious can mean only one thing: desperately trying to create Halloween content that stands out from the rest of the year!

It's another one about urban legends. What more do you need to know?

The boys have finally gone out and done something interesting! Or at least, kind of interesting. Either way, they're sure gonna share it with you!

It's gross bug week on Superduperstitious, because why the hell not?

Superduperstitious is splashing into summer with some sea-inspired stories! Or at least, that was the plan.

This week, it's an adventure into the woods for some ridiculous rigatoni!

It would be a rare day indeed that Superduperstitious would fail to pay lip service to some ancient reptilian friends.

29 more episodes deep since their first sound adventure and Wyatt and Jake are again reminded that podcasts are in fact an audio-based medium.

Without a specific theme to this week's episode, ANYTHING can happen! But really just two things happen.

Would it really be an episode of Superduperstitious without some monsters? Perhaps. But it wouldn't be THIS episode.

It's high time Superduperstitious took another look skyward, so this week's episode once again handles those interplanetary interlopers, extraterrestrials!

The world sure does seem to have a lot of haunted places in it, huh? Like, at least several. And not all of them are even houses or abandoned prisons!

For us humans, it stands to reason that oodles of spooky stories focus on beings that are MOSTLY human, but not quite enough for comfort. It's certainly the case on this week's episode!

Somehow it took 28 episodes to finally get around to covering lake monsters, but here we are! And don't you worry: this one's got more logs and waves and misidentified loons than you can shake a moose at.

It's a health-conscious week as the boys embark on a superstition-fueled journey into New England's past.

This week, it's all about them artifact facts! The mysterious relics in question have some pretty far out stories behind them, and the boys are determined to dig in deep.

Has it really been a whole year? No? Well the boys have an anniversary of sorts to celebrate nonetheless, and they do it with a return to some spooky favorites!

After checking in again on the British Invasion (the Spring Heeled Jack one, that is), the boys examine some longstanding, almost elemental legends from different parts of the world.

Well if it isn't another new episode! This week, Wyatt jumps on that opening-update-segment-train with some ghastly tales of Spring Heeled Jack's move to America, where he gets into some very specific routines.

Phantoms abound in this fright-filled episode! After a correction to last week's story that makes it somehow even more upsetting to the boys, Jake discusses a bandage-covered spook that haunts a lonely Oregon road.

It's another week, and the boys' fascination with the not-quite-human never ceases!

There once was a dorky podcast that discussed paranormal phenomena from a scientific perspective. One night, they decided to discuss urban legends again, since there are, like, a billion of those.

What the folk? It's a new episode! And it's goofy as all get-out. This week, the boys are examining legends and folktales that seemingly are true even today.

Monsters! Everyone likes those, right? Well there are two of 'em in this week's episode, and no, they're not the hosts (DO YOU SEE WHAT WE DID THERE?!).

Wyatt and Jake crank up the spooks once more with some tales of hauntings! Wait, didn't they get, like, abducted at the end of the last episode? It's probably fine.

As the temperature keeps dropping, the boys take refuge in stories of more tropical climes, beginning with a herpetological journey through a century of astounding claims from the Amazon.

Brrrr! It's the winter solstice up in the Northern Hemisphere, so it's time for some tales of cold weather creepiness to fit the mood.

Wyatt and Jake are back on it again with another foray into cryptozoology — and what a foray it is!

After a gap week spent finding themselves, the boys are ready to crank up them spooks!

Who said you can't make an episode of a paranormal podcast Thanksgiving-themed?

Are you prospiracy or conspiracy? This week, Wyatt explores two famous cases of bizarre military experimentation that led to a perhaps popular Netflix series, all while he and Jake overcome some past Muppet trauma.

Did you hear about the latest episode of Superduperstitious? I didn't listen to it, but I know this one guy whose cousin totally did and OH MAN. That's right — this episode is about urban legends!

Is it a sea monster? Is it bugs? No, it's a new episode of Superduperstitious! Listen to Wyatt and Jake as THEY listen to some weird sounds — so meta!

It's time again to talk about spooky stuff — but now in a SEASONAL way!

Wyatt spins a spooky tale of some unexplained experiences he had after moving into an old house in western Massachusetts — you'll never guess how much mail and lady bones are hidden in that place! 

This week, Jake walks us through a surprisingly recent and ongoing epidemic of giant bat creature sightings in Chicago.

In the inaugural episode of Superduperstitious, Wyatt Shell and Jake Withee talk about their favorite cryptids.